Menu
News

Wagners do not want a jury for Alan Jones defamation case

The Wagner family is suing shock jock Alan Jones for
The Wagner family is suing shock jock Alan Jones for "implying” the Wagner quarry caused the Lockyer Valley floods. Danial Tuck

A JURY could face up to 900 individual legal decisions potentially taking weeks to decide if shock jock Alan Jones defamed Toowoomba's wealthy Wagner family.

The Wagners on Thursday applied for the defamation trial to be heard in front of a judge-only, claiming the matter more complex than any previous defamation trial heard in Australia.

The Wagners have sued Mr Jones and his employer the Harbour Radio company over 32 broadcasts during which the family alleges the radio host falsely "implied” the family's quarry was to blame for the disastrous 2011 Lockyer Valley floods.

The Brisbane Supreme Court on Thursday heard the Wagners believed the matter was so complicated a jury would take weeks to reach a verdict and might "invite error”.

Mr Jones's lawyers have rejected the allegations and are defending the action. The court heard Mr Jones would maintain his comments were not defamatory as they were true.

Wagners' lawyer Tom Blackburn said the jury might have to make up to 900 individual legal decisions to decide if Mr Jones had defamed the family.

He said it would be more practical for a single judge to come to a decision and publish his reasons than expect a jury to reach a unanimous verdict on so many issues.

"How is the jury going to cope with the demands of this case?” Mr Blackburn said.

"It's an invitation, your honour, for the trial to go off the rails.”

Mr Jones's lawyer Rob Anderson said a jury could not be avoided simply because the trial was complicated.

"Simply saying this is a big case is not enough to dispense with the jury,” he said.

"The jury is being asked to do the same thing 32 times. If it was 50 or 100 times it would still be the same.”

Mr Blackburn said the sheer number of defamatory broadcasts was "unprecedented”.

"Most defamation cases have one or two or three or maybe four defamatory allegations. There are 32 here,” he said.

Justice Peter Applegarth will deliver his decision at a later date. - NewsRegional

Topics:  alan jones defamation lockyer valley floods supreme court wagners


Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Commuter chaos: Exploded road strands CQ workers, students

The huge crack is believed to be a result of a mine black at Moura Mine.

WHO will foot the bill after mine blast split major transport route?

VOTING EARLY? Where to find your closest pre-polling station

Ballot to decide the order the candidates will appear in the 2016 council Election. The candidates numbers are put into envelopes and then the ballot box. Photo Mike Richards / The Observer

Where you can vote if you want to avoid election day crowds.

VIDEO AT SITE: Mine blast split CQ road in two

DAMAGE: The huge crack is believed to be a result of a mine blast at Moura Mine.

UPDATE: Road closures will be in place for several weeks

Local Partners